30+ Best First Fathers Day Gifts for All New Dads 2025

The arrival of a baby is a monumental occasion, and a new dad's first Father's Day marks a truly special milestone. Whether it's for a new dad cherishing his newborn or an expecting dad eagerly awaiting his little one, we've included some heartfelt first Father's Day gifts, ensuring you find just the right way to say "Happy First Father's Day!"

First Father's Day Gift Ideas to Capture the Journey

These 1st Father's Day gifts focus on commemorating the early moments of fatherhood with keepsakes that last a lifetime.

• Personalized Photo Canvas

This beautiful canvas print allows you to personalize it with a cherished photo of the new dad and baby, alongside their names and a special date. The first Father's Day gift is perfect for close relationships, like a spouse or partner, due to its sentimental value.

Daddy You are the World Canvas

Shop Now

The vibrant colors and sharp image quality make it a beautiful addition to any home. I appreciate the range of size options, which cater to different spaces.  I think this custom gift beautifully captures the essence of early fatherhood. 

Gifts First Fathers Day - Personalized The Very Night You Became My Great Daddy Canvas

Shop Now

• Baby Handprint & Footprint Keepsake Kit

It’s intimate and creative, great for bonding while capturing tiny hands and feet forever, perfect choice if you're looking for Father's Day gifts for your husband. I gave this to a friend and saw how much joy it brought. While a bit messy, the process was fun and meaningful.

• Personalized Photo Album or Scrapbook

This first father's day gift encourages the new dad to document the precious early moments of his child's life. Depending on the size and features, some high-quality albums can be a bit pricey, but the lasting value makes it worthwhile.

• Engraved Wooden Picture Frame
  

Ideal for close relationships, this first Father's Day gift is both decorative and sentimental. I’ve seen similar products, but this one stands out for its affordability. It holds a standard 4x6 photo and comes with a stand for easy display. Perfect as a Father's Day gift for boyfriend, husband, or any man. 

• Custom Puzzle - "Daddy & Me Time"

Fun, lighthearted, and interactive. A great activity to enjoy as the child grows. This one surprised me with how high-quality the pieces felt. I think it’s a great way to turn memories into play.

• A Subscription Box for New Parents

Subscription Box for New Parents

A curated box delivered regularly, filled with items tailored for new parents and babies, such as developmental toys, baby care products, or even snacks and self-care items for the parents. This new dad father's day gift offers ongoing support and surprises. 

• Engraved Pocket Knife

This 1st Father's Day gift is mid-range and suits dads who enjoy practical, outdoor-friendly items. The wooden handle adds a nice touch, and the engraving is precise. Compared to other knives, it’s reasonably priced.

Father's Day Gifts for New Dads That Celebrate His Role

These father's day gifts for new dads highlight the pride and joy of fatherhood with practical and heartfelt options.

• Personalized First Father's Day T-Shirt

This first-time dad gift is perfect for casual wear and makes a fun statement during Father's Day brunch or baby outings. It's affordable, lighthearted, and a wearable way to acknowledge his new role.

First Fathers Day Gifts From Baby Boy - Personalized Like Father Like Son T Shirts

Shop Now

First Father's Day Gift Ideas - Personalized Daddy's Gang T-Shirt

Shop Now

I’m really impressed with the Personal House Personalized First Father's Day T-Shirt. The cotton feels incredibly soft, and I love how vibrant the custom print looks even after multiple washes. This item is so hot, so order early to avoid delays!

New Dad Level Unlocked Shirt

Shop Now

• Personalized First Father's Day Mug

A ceramic mug customizable with dad’s name, baby’s photo, or a heartfelt message. It’s dishwasher-safe and holds 11 oz, perfect for coffee or tea.

Daddy First Fathers Day Gifts from Daughter- Personalized Best Dad Looks Like Mug

Shop Now

Father's Day Gifts For New Dads - Personalized Dad Nutrition Facts Mug

Shop Now

This personalized Father's Day gift suits any new dad. Its practicality makes it a daily-use item, while the personalization conveys love. 

• UGG Men's Robinson Robe

Personally, I think a comfortable robe is a wonderful Father Day gift for a new dad who deserves some pampering. UGG is known for its soft and cozy materials, and the Robinson Robe seems like a perfect example.

Men's Robinson Robe

• Matching Outfits for Dad and Baby

Coordinated dad t-shirt and baby onesie sets with funny or sweet phrases like "Big Guy / Little Guy" or "Copy / Paste". Perfect for photo ops and making memories, these 1st Father's Day gifts add humor and bonding. 

I’ve gifted matching sets to friends, and they were always a hit. Just be sure to double-check baby sizing—some brands run small.

• Custom Socks - "Best Dad Ever"

Quirky, cozy, and clever, this is one of the more creative first Father's Day gift ideas. Ideal for homebodies or dads with a fun fashion sense. It could be great if you are looking for a gift for your brother, best friend, or even your husband!

>>>> See more Father's Day gift ideas for brother here

• Customized Bottle Opener

I really enjoy the charm of the Customized Bottle Opener. It’s compact yet feels solid, and the engraving gives it a thoughtful edge. I love this frist Father's Day gift  because it’s so affordable yet still personal, perfect for casual gifting.

First Father's Day Gifts for Bonding with Baby

These first Father's Day gifts encourage special moments between dad and baby, fostering their connection.

• Melissa & Doug Soft Blocks - Farm Animals

The Melissa & Doug Soft Blocks - Farm Animals set includes six lightweight and squeezable fabric blocks featuring colorful illustrations of friendly farm animals. This first father's day gift idea promotes early sensory exploration and provides a fun way for the new dad to interact with his baby.

Melissa & Doug Soft Blocks

• Baby Milestone Cards - The Original Mudpie Baby Milestone Cards
  

A set of 30 illustrated cardstock cards from Mudpie to capture moments like “First Smile” or “First Tooth” is a great 1st Father's Day gift for any relationship. I used a similar set for my nephew, and it was so fun snapping photos of his “First Giggle.” Some parents wish there were more cards for later milestones, but I think 30 is plenty.

• Baby Carrier - Ergonomic Soft Carrier

For new dad Father's Day gifts, nothing beats hands-free bonding. This carrier is practical for walks, errands, or just moving around the house. I gifted one to a first-time dad, and he said it gave him confidence when carrying his newborn.

•  Tubby Todd Hair & Body Wash and Bath Toys Set

This father's day gift for new dads combines a practical necessity with elements that make bath time a fun bonding experience. The gentle wash ensures the baby's comfort, while the bath toys provide opportunities for playful interaction and sensory stimulation during bath time with dad.

Hair & Body Wash and Bath Toys Set

• Sensory Play Kit for Dads
  

I think this idea is underrated. It’s interactive and educational, and you can pick kits suited to different development stages. Just ensure the materials are BPA-free. It's a thoughtful, hands-on first Father's Day gift for building connections. 

Father's Day Gifts for Expecting Dads

These father's day gifts for expecting dads celebrate the anticipation of fatherhood with thoughtful, future-focused gifts.

• Personalized Dad-to-Be Photo Mug

This father's day gift for dad to be is ideal for close relationships. Its practicality and sentimentality convey excitement and support, perfect for daily use.

Personalized Your're Going To Be Amazing Dad Mug

Buy Now

Personalized Where You Becomes A Daddy Mug

Buy Now

Personal House’s customization lets you add both a photo and text, which feels extra special, and online reviews rave about its vibrant colors. I gifted a similar mug to my cousin during her pregnancy, and her husband used it daily, beaming with pride.

•  Personalized Dad-to-Be Poster

This first father's day gift expectant dads is a lighthearted and visual way to celebrate his impending fatherhood. 

Personalized Daddy Our Adventure Is About To Start Poster

Available Now

I adore how this gift visualizes the emotional journey ahead. It’s optimistic and charming. The print quality is vibrant, and framing it elevates the look instantly.

• Customized Dad-to-Be Journal - Papier Personalized Wellness Journal
  

A hardcover journal from Papier, embossed with “Dad-to-Be” and the expecting dad’s name is a perfect father's day gift for expectant dads. The fabric cover feels luxurious, and the guided prompts are so thoughtful for capturing a dad-to-be’s emotions.

• A Gift Certificate for a Prenatal Massage for Couples

I think a couples' prenatal massage is a wonderful and thoughtful first Father's Day gift. Choosing a reputable spa with experience in prenatal massage is important for safety and comfort. This gift promotes well-being and togetherness.

•  Custom Calendar - "Countdown to Fatherhood"

This one is so fun! I love how it adds structure to the countdown. I suggest pairing it with some small weekly notes or surprise stickers for added charm. A unique and functional first Father's Day gift that helps dads stay involved.

Conclusion

From the Personal House Personalized Photo Canvas to the Dad-to-Be Photo Mug, these first Father's Day gifts blend sentimentality, practicality, and style. Each gift is a heartfelt way to celebrate the journey of fatherhood, creating memories that last a lifetime.